TenantSee Weekly: The Great Reset and Rent
The so called “capital stack”, the money investors and lenders have put into an office building investment, has recently been the subject of much discussion in markets like San Francisco. In many cases, the stack is broken, meaning the investor has lost all its equity and the value of the lender’s position is compromised, as well. We’ve reached a point at which these financial partners have concluded there is no path forward for the investment, leaving only one option: sell. This is how the Great Reset begins. It’s exemplified in the sale of buildings like 350 California Street, an asset that would have traded in the $800/sf+ range prior to the pandemic, but which traded in the $250/sf range this year.
TenantSee Weekly: The Artificial Floor
Currently, there’s a lot of downward pressure on rental rates in the San Francisco office market. This is caused by a massive uptick in available space (4% to over 30+%), the proliferation of subleases in which the sublandlord is motivated to mitigate cost, not achieve target NOI, and the presence of owners having a materially lower cost basis, either through a long-term hold strategy, or a recent acquisition at steeply discounted pricing, both of whom can compete at much lower rental economics. Indeed, the economics being offered by these parties stands in stark contrast to those offered by landlords who bought or refinanced in the years running up to the pandemic. This latter category, by the way, encompasses a large swath of the market. These investors are struggling against a confluence of factors, including rising interest rates, maturing debt, rising insurance costs, decreased demand, lack of capital, and valuation outcomes that put equity and debt underwater.